← Complete research archive
Evaluation & auditsResult63 lines

R12 RGDE Relational Identity Carrier Result

Decision: reject rgde relational identity carrier

R12_RGDE_RELATIONAL_IDENTITY_RESULT.mdOpen original Markdown ↗

R12 RGDE Relational Identity Carrier Result

Decision: reject_rgde_relational_identity_carrier

The ordered carrier is highly accurate in absolute terms but fails its frozen attribution gate. Do not promote or integrate it from this result.

Custody

  • Source/prereg commit 7392002 preceded the first production seed attempt.
  • That attempt wrote no board and retired seed 9306354405723368031 after a static 512-groups-versus-six-depths validation defect.
  • Correction commit 94f8d1b preceded production seed 18136108174735860272.
  • The admitted public board has 512 semantic quartets / 2,048 rows, 6,136 source cards, 800,803 source tokens, and 1,536 fresh paired names.
  • Every overlap, span, factor, executor, quartet, and depth-balance gate passes.
  • Board SHA-256: ba2b0d4817ffe68f004978b6a403aba893db17aa49878afb6548a71b9219b596.
  • Job 693125 completed once on H100 evc29 in 75 seconds, exit 0:0, with zero fit updates and zero confirmation access.
  • Result SHA-256: 138b855e253f2d6faf415d36522dab60ad38f1172d66cece1677a6f785703a6e.

Scores

There are 11,248 active operation-to-introduction identity references.

MethodCorrectAccuracy
Existing lexical mean, T=110,95797.413%
Unordered vocabulary mass, T=0.511,16999.298%
Ordered sequence, T=111,21499.698%
Ordered sequence, T=0.5 primary11,20999.653%
Ordered sequence, T=0.2511,20899.644%
Gold-span ordered ceiling11,248100.000%

The primary is at least 99.346% at every depth and 99.573% on every surface. It exceeds the unordered bag and proves that ordered role-token identity is recoverable without fitting. However, the existing mean control is also much stronger on this board than the frozen end-to-end depth result suggested. The primary gain is only 2.240 points, not the required 15 points. Five of six gates pass; the attribution gate fails.

Interpretation

This experiment does not establish that mean-vector compression is the causal end-to-end bottleneck. It establishes a narrower fact: the frozen compiler's soft role masks contain enough information for a fixed ordered kernel to recover composed identity almost perfectly on a disjoint public board. The large discrepancy between raw mean-cosine identity here (97.413%) and the frozen executor's learned entity-match head on the failed depth board (77.952%) now points at the consumer interface as a plausible failure source.

The next admissible experiment is a no-fit matched executor diagnostic on this public board: compare the exact frozen packet/executor against the same packet whose operation identity is rebound to one of its three initial-entity vectors by the ordered relation. That test may localize transport loss, but this failed carrier cannot be promoted from it and the sealed depth board may not be read.

No autonomous planning, learned halt, language reasoning, or novelty claim is authorized.