R12 RGDE Recurrent-Depth Confirmation Result
Decision: reject_rgde_depth_confirmation
Strong diagnostic: the frozen recurrent executor itself confirms through depth eight under gold packets; the primary predicted packet fails on unseen paired-name grounding. Do not refit or rerun this confirmation board.
Custody
- Source/preregistration commit
85ead2epreceded production seed11772835344958352982. - The 2,048-row / 6,136-card / 798,346-token board passed every CPU/data gate.
- Board SHA-256:
742899905a39c0afc4575e94ff533d489aaf42992c248ddf4668f44609eab2d0. - Job
693124ran once on H100evc29. It wrote primary, gold, and operation control outputs, then exited1:0because the depth-stratified query labels made a full within-depth derangement impossible. There was no fit, retry, alternate seed, or old-confirmation access. - Safe evidence archive SHA-256:
ec795b89683451e1f495e902a9db3fc8b736f23f4d4076ee7cbdcc1db7a20663.
The missing query control and failed Slurm receipt independently fail gate 10. The primary scores already fail gates 2--7, so no replacement control can change the rejection decision.
Primary predicted packet
| Depth | Answers | Exact final state | All transitions | Entity match |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3 | 79.651% | 76.453% | 61.337% | 82.752% |
| 4 | 78.779% | 73.256% | 56.395% | 82.922% |
| 5 | 81.471% | 72.059% | 46.471% | 79.118% |
| 6 | 72.059% | 65.294% | 35.294% | 76.765% |
| 7 | 78.824% | 72.941% | 41.765% | 77.647% |
| 8 | 67.059% | 55.294% | 23.824% | 74.044% |
| overall | 76.318% | 69.238% | 44.238% | 77.952% |
Amount is 100% and query is 99.707%. Every surface lies between 75.000% and 78.516% answers; only 243/512 quartets have all four answers correct. The error accumulates with depth because operation-to-initial entity identity is already wrong on roughly 22% of atomic packets.
Gold-packet localization
| Depth | Answers | Exact final state | All transitions | Entity match |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3 | 99.419% | 100.000% | 99.419% | 100.000% |
| 4 | 99.709% | 100.000% | 97.965% | 100.000% |
| 5 | 100.000% | 100.000% | 99.412% | 100.000% |
| 6 | 100.000% | 100.000% | 99.706% | 100.000% |
| 7 | 100.000% | 100.000% | 99.118% | 100.000% |
| 8 | 99.118% | 100.000% | 98.824% | 100.000% |
| overall | 99.707% | 100.000% | 99.072% | 100.000% |
This is the main scientific result. The same 1,491,279-parameter cell was trained only on independent atomic updates and never on depth 3--8. With the compiler interface repaired by gold role spans/kinds, it maintains exact state through eight recurrent calls. There is no intrinsic recurrent-state collapse at this depth.
The 23.389-point answer gap and 30.762-point final-state gap between predicted and gold localize the failure to Stage A packet grounding on the new hyphenated paired names. Those names are compositionally novel relative to the compiler's single nonce-name training distribution.
Causal operation control
Replacing every operation stream with a different same-depth program reduces answers to 32.275%, exact final state to 13.428%, and all-transition exactness to 0.244%, while query remains 99.707%. The executor is consuming operation packets causally; its positive gold depth score is not an inert-state shortcut.
Next admissible move
Preserve this board as a sealed negative and never fit on it. The next development experiment must target compositional referent grounding on a new, disjoint public paired-name board. A no-fit relational carrier should compare role-weighted token sets before source deletion rather than compressing each referent independently to one mean vector. Only after that interface passes a new development board may a second, independently seeded depth confirmation be designed.
The confirmed current capability is therefore precise: the native tied executor generalizes its atomic update rule through depth eight when supplied correct bounded packets; the ordinary compiler does not yet ground novel composed entity names reliably enough for end-to-end confirmation.